Good call! Dying to know if you're right...
*******************
~Anne Troy

www.OfficeArticles.com


"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Since you're seeing the SaveAs dialog, it sounds like excel knows that
this file
can't be overwritten.

If you look at the title bar, do you see [Read-Only] there?

If you do, then either the user opened the workbook in readonly mode. Or
the
file could have its attributes set to ReadOnly (via windows explorer???).
Or it
could mean that the user doesn't have write access to that drive/folder.

If there's another user who has the file open, this user may have ignored
the
message that said it was in use and answered "yes" to the readonly prompt.

==========

Arrrrrrgggggggghhhh!

My "real" guess (after re-reading your post).

I bet that user who is having the trouble double clicks on the file in
windows
explorer to open it.

If you walk by that user's pc and ask them to rightclick on that file (in
windows explorer), you should see one option in bold letters. For most
people,
Open should be the default action for .xls files.

But I'm guessing you see New in bold. That means that windows/excel will
treat
that file (and all .xls files) as a template.

One way to fix this is:

Close Excel and
Windows Start Button|Run
excel /unregserver
then
Windows Start Button|Run
excel /regserver

The /unregserver & /regserver stuff resets the windows registry to excel's
factory defaults.


=========
Yeah, I could have deleted that first portion of my post. But it was a
lot of
typing and it could have been useful <vbg.




dmtech wrote:

I just re-checked to make sure of the extension, it is definitly xls.
The
filename is the current month and day as 5-29 for today when you click
on the
save icon you get a Save as box with a filename of 5-291 with an
extension of
xls with the default folder selected instead of the folder where the
file
came from. Prior to this week, when you click on the save icon it just
saved
the file over the original. This system is used by several people, on
different shifts, week-end shifts, and fill-ins for vacations and sick
calls.
The file is an event log and the officer on duty enters data in at least
once
an hour, everything has worked OK for the past several years and just
started
to have problems, no one will admit to makeing any changes in the file.
Re-installing the master, which is write protected on the network makes
no
improvement. The same master installed on other computers works OK.
--
dmtech

"Anne Troy" wrote:

1,2,3? Sounds like the file was saved as a template. Are you sure the
file
name is XLS and not XLT?
*******************
~Anne Troy

www.OfficeArticles.com


"dmtech" wrote in message
...
Using Excel97. when my user opens a file, makes changes and then
clicks
the
save icon, it used to save the changes to the file that was
originally
opened, now it brings up a save as dialog box, adds a 1,2,3.... to
the
filename and saves it in the default folder instead of where it came
from.
How do I put it back to the way it was
--
dmtech




--

Dave Peterson